NeoProgBlog, The Neoprogressive Magazine online

'Work as if you lived in the early days of a better nation.' Alasdair Gray

Welcome to The NeoProgressive, where people of all political persuasions can debate vigorously within a framework of basic American values and mutual respect -- NeoProgressivism.

VISITORS: PLEASE COMMENT! I want to stimulate discussion, not be a voice in the wilderness.

(NeoProgBlog, The Neoprogressive, The Neoprogressive Magazine, and original material © 2005, 2006.)

Tuesday, September 07, 2010


Update, Sept. 8: Allah be praised, someone has an even better idea. Please support these guys.

Original post:

In the Founders' concept of the "Marketplace of Ideas," bad ideas won't find as many buyers as good ones -- so good ideas ultimately will win. Here's a plan to put that concept to work.

"The NeoProgressive" generally is not intended to take sides in passing political debates. Its goal is to look past hotbutton issues to look for ways Americans of varying opinions can join together to pursue common, truly American objectives. My focus here is ideological, not inflammatory.

But sometimes events occur that call for citizens of good will to stop merely talking about principles, and start acting on them. This is such a time.

The misguided and misanthropic pastor of Florida's Dove World Outreach Center church has announced plans to burn thousands of Korans on September 11. He's doing this despite a clear warning from David H. Petraeus, the American general in charge of operations in Afghanistan, that doing so would jeopardize both the lives of American troops and prospects for success in that war:

"It could endanger troops and it could endanger the overall effort in Afghanistan," Petraeus said. "Were the actual burning to take place, the safety of our soldiers and civilians would be put in jeopardy and accomplishment of the mission would be made more difficult," he said.

Of course, in America, private individuals are free to both publish books and to burn them. The Constitution guarantees free expression, including offensive expression. But, if the Founders' "marketplace of ideas" concept is correct, there should be many more right-thinking people willing to print books than there are wrong-thinking people willing to burn them.

Accordingly, the NeoProgressive is gathering pledges from people who are willing to pay the costs of printing and distributing at least twice as many Korans as the Dove World Outreach Center burns on 9/11.

I don't propose this for religious reasons. I'm not Muslim. The book's content doesn't matter; what matters is establishing that more Americans support freedom of religion and expression than oppose them, and that there are more compassionate, tolerant Americans than there are narrow-minded, intolerant ones. By causing there to be more Korans in the world on 9/12 than there were on 9/10, we will be standing up for American ideals. And, if the same news media that cover the Koran-burning also report that Americans have created more Korans than they destroyed, we might even help save America's reputation in the world's Islamic community -- and, consequently, American soldiers' lives.

If enough people show interest in this project, I'll do the legwork needed to determine the exact costs involved and propose a method of distribution. At this point, I'd just like to know who's interested in participating and how much money we may have to work with.

If you think Korans4Korans is a good idea, please send me an email at Korans4Korans at gmail dot com, with your name, email, and what you might be able to contribute to the effort (in both money and skills -- I'm a mediator and writer and would love to connect with people who really know how the mechanics of this might work). And please follow the #Korans4Korans hashtag on Twitter.

M.S. Bellows, Jr.

Labels: , , , ,


Blogger Dee said...

It is a filthy, unAmerican crime to burn ANY religion's book. I am half minded to burn a Bible, but that would be merely sinking to the ignorant, hateful level of these people who allow fear and stupidity to rule them. My mind boggles at the cruel disrespect that they display, fuel for the fires of the fellow extremists who created the situation in the first place. You are no Christians who perform this act, just as the people who destroyed and killed thousands nine years ago were not true Muslims!

Didn't Jesus himself say, "Blessed are the peacemakers"?

9/08/2010 7:05 AM  
Blogger cmn's blog said...

It's a stupid idea to burn it, but it is his right...kinda like the 9/11 mosque: it is their right to build it, but it's a stupid idea to build it there. So many are on opposite side on the two ideas it's a bit amusing. The other thing is, back when the "art" "Piss Christ" was getting Christians upset (as this Koran burning is getting Muslims upset) I don't recall any movement to raise $$ to buy more crucifixes or other Christian representations. Why does this act (burning the Koran) warrant such a fundraiser when the other did not? Just wondering. Is burning a religious book more sacred than a sacred image?

9/08/2010 7:16 AM  
Blogger M.S. Bellows, Jr. said...

cmn's blog: There's a difference. Christians are offended by desecration of religious images or Bibles, but not mortally offended, because Christians don't consider the physical object sacred. Muslims, however, consider any phsyical manifestation of the words of the Koran to be sacred -- almost an incarnation of the Divine. To them, burning a Koran is more hurtful even than "Piss Christ" was to Christian conservatives.

But I'm an equal-opportunity NeoProgressive; if someone were burning Bibles and doing so put American troops' lives at risk, I like to think I'd do the same thing.

9/08/2010 10:49 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home